Final Brand Resources thought leader group

Discover expert advice from Marketing Association thought leaders on Black Friday marketing, retail promotions, customer behaviour, discounting and protecting long-term brand value.

As retailers and consumers alike approach Black Friday, our Marketing Association Thought Leadership Group considered what advice they’d offer retail marketers looking to freshen up the now-predictable major trading weekends.

One thing the group agreed on is the tension between meeting customer expectations and creating those expectations in the first place. Retailers have successfully trained consumers to anticipate major sales weekends, but that creates a cycle in which customers question everyday prices and delay purchasing.

As Denelle Joyce, Chair of our Brand, Customer & Leadership group, observes from a consumer perspective:

“We all know there are certain retailers where you’d never pay RRP because we’ve learned that their best prices come during traditional long weekends and major sales events. As a result, these retailers are effectively training their customers to wait for sales.”

But opting out isn’t always easy, particularly when customers are primed to shop.

Fiona Taimana, from The Warehouse Group, where she leads Noel Leeming marketing, highlights the commercial reality:

“We have trained our customers to shop these weekends. The challenge is that ALL retailers advertise, so it costs more for share of voice.”

Major trading weekends certainly present opportunities, but competing on discounts alone risks eroding brand value, margins and customer trust.

Four things the group would do:

  1. Understand customer behaviour and offer genuine, relevant value.
  2. Be distinctive. Communicate early, target smartly and stand out from competitors.
  3. Promote benefits, not just prices, reinforcing what makes your brand valuable.
  4. Measure profitability, customer response, and longer-term impact, including opportunities beyond the retail frenzy.

Four things the group would avoid:

  1. Training customers to wait for predictable sales.
  2. Discounting unnecessarily or sacrificing margins for turnover.
  3. Copying competitors or creating artificial urgency.
  4. Assuming louder promotions guarantee better results or overlooking their impact on other sectors, including charities.

And what about the for-purpose sector?

Annabel Lush, from Blood Cancer New Zealand, brings another interesting perspective. With inboxes overflowing with retail promotions and consumers focused on shopping, charities are also competing for attention and donations.

But interestingly, shopping and giving aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive.

“Overseas research suggests discounts can sometimes encourage giving when shoppers feel they saved money, but that effect weakens when they think they overspent.”

Annabel suggests testing campaign timing rather than assuming donations will suffer. She also points to the growing adoption of Giving Tuesday by New Zealand charities, providing a meaningful opportunity to seek support on the Tuesday following the Black Friday frenzy.

Read the research on promotions and generosity

As Mike Kotlyar, from @consult marketing consultancy, puts it:

“Customers may expect promotions, but marketers shouldn’t automatically follow the crowd. Sometimes protecting brand value delivers greater long-term returns.”

And that really is the point.

Sometimes it’s worth zigging while others zag. One example of doing things differently was Patagonia’s famous 2011 Black Friday campaign, “Don’t Buy This Jacket”, which challenged consumerism rather than encouraging it. Interestingly, the company subsequently reported sales growth of approximately 30% in 2012.

Read about Patagonia’s campaign

The group’s recommendations reinforce what marketers already know, but sometimes have to navigate with hungry stakeholders looking for a short-term shot in the arm.

Annabel Lush

Black Friday and other major trading weekends can impact For Purpose organisations fundraising, but it doesn’t automatically make Kiwis more or less generous. A marketing challenge is competition - retail promotions crowd inboxes, compete for attention, and may squeeze donation budgets. However, overseas research suggests discounts can sometimes encourage giving when shoppers feel they saved money, but that effect weakens when they think they overspent. It’s important to test timing rather than assume donations will fail and to compare results from other campaigns. Many charities in New Zealand have “adopted” the American Giving Tuesday, seeking support in a meaningful way on the Tuesday AFTER the Black Friday marketing frenzy.

Fiona Taimana

Peak retail trading weekends

We have trained our customers to shop these weekends; the challenge is that ALL retailers advertise, so it costs more for share of voice. I always start communicating the offers to our existing customer database/followers using emails and organic posts, to promote our special offers, two to three days prior to the weekend.

  • Advertise good, strong deals to drive foot traffic in-store
  • Spend slightly more in channels where you know your customers will be - eg online to create awareness for the high value products that are considered purchases
  • Focus on seasonal products relevant to the long weekend - e.g. summertime - cooling products
  • Create some theatre in-store to call out the “hot offers” - Front of store, bulk stacks etc.

Mike Kotlar

Major trading weekends offer opportunities, but can also undermine brand equity.

Four things I'd do: Understand customer behaviour, offer genuine value, reinforce brand positioning, and measure profitability.

Four things I'd avoid: Unnecessary discounting, artificial urgency, copying competitors, and sacrificing long-term brand value for short-term sales.

Patagonia's famous 2011 Black Friday campaign, "Don't Buy This Jacket", challenged consumerism rather than encouraging it. Interestingly, the company subsequently reported sales growth of approximately 30% in 2012.

My takeaway? Customers may expect promotions, but marketers shouldn't automatically follow the crowd. Sometimes protecting brand value delivers greater long-term returns.

Denelle Joyce

From a consumer's perspective

I wonder whether consumers are becoming increasingly wary of purchasing during major trading weekends, particularly big-ticket items, only to discover prices have dropped even further after they've bought.

We all know there are certain retailers where you'd never pay RRP because we've learned that their best prices come during traditional long weekends and major sales events. As a result, these retailers are effectively training their customers to wait for sales.

What I'd do:

  1. Understand the true market value of your products. Do your best to price them fairly and competitively every day, rather than relying on inflated RRPs and regular discounting.
  2. Be less predictable. If you're going to have a sale, vary the timing. Don't train your customers to know exactly when they should wait to buy.
  3. Lead with customer value. What problem does your product solve? Be confident in your promotions and lead with the classic "What's in it for me?" Understand your customers and what represents genuine value to them.
  4. Be commercially aware of your competitors. Are they pulling your customers out of the market? You may feel the need to compete with a promotion of your own, but look for ways to make your offer distinctive. Could a bundle deliver better value without simply cutting prices?
  5. Make the most of competitor activity. If competitors are advertising heavily, think about how you can benefit from the demand they're creating. Consumers are savvy and will shop around. Zig while others zag.

What I wouldn't do:

  1. Feel compelled to copy competitors. Be distinctive in your offers, messaging, and approach.
  2. Create predictable discounting patterns. You're simply teaching customers to defer their purchases until the next sale.
  3. Rely on loss leaders or discount indiscriminately. Don't destroy margins across product lines or categories in pursuit of turnover.
  4. Confuse sales volume with valuable pricing insight. Understanding what customers are genuinely prepared to pay for individual products is far more valuable than celebrating a big weekend turnover figure. Heavy discounting can distort your learnings about demand, price sensitivity and true market value.

Author:  Annabel Lush, Fiona Taimana & Mike Kotlyar, 17th November 2026.